The ‘Near Me’ Challenge: Who’s Winning Google in Your Town?

Lynda Ofume • September 9, 2025

Share this article

If you’ve ever searched for “coffee shop near me” or “best plumber near me,” you’ve experienced one of the biggest shifts in digital marketing – the rise of ‘near me’ searches. Today, customers expect instant, hyper-local results, and Google is the referee deciding which businesses win that coveted top spot.


But here’s the real challenge: in your town, some businesses are quietly dominating “near me” results, pulling in traffic, phone calls, and foot traffic – while others don’t even appear. The question is: are you winning, or are your competitors?


Why “Near Me” Searches Matter More Than Ever


  • Explosive Growth: “Near me” searches have increased by over 500% in the past few years.
  • High Intent: These users aren’t browsing – they’re ready to buy, book, or visit.
  • Mobile First: With most searches happening on smartphones, location-based results drive immediate action.

When Google shows the top 3 results in its “local pack,” that’s prime real estate. If you’re not in that map box, you’re invisible to a huge chunk of potential customers.


Who’s Winning in Your Town?


The businesses leading local search typically do three things better than everyone else:


1. Optimized Google Business Profiles


They’ve claimed, completed, and regularly updated their Google Business Profile (formerly Google My Business). Photos, opening hours, reviews, and FAQs – everything is polished.


2. Reviews and Reputation


Top-ranking businesses actively request reviews, respond to feedback, and showcase their reputation as a trust signal to both Google and potential customers.


3. Local SEO Strategy


They’re using location-specific keywords, creating local content, and building backlinks from regional sources. This signals to Google that they’re a credible, relevant choice.


How to Compete (and Win)


If you’re not showing up in “near me” searches, don’t panic – it’s fixable. Here’s where to start:


  • Claim and optimize your Google Business Profile.
  • Encourage reviews from happy customers and reply to each one.
  • Use local keywords on your website (think “Charlottetown bakery” instead of just “bakery”).
  • Add location pages if you serve multiple towns.
  • Check competitors – see what they’re doing right, then do it better.


Final Word: Your Town’s Google Map Is the New Main Street



Once upon a time, businesses competed for the busiest street corner. Today, they compete for the top spot in Google’s “near me” results. The businesses that treat local SEO seriously are already reaping the benefits – are you one of them?


If you’re ready to claim your spot in the local pack and stop losing customers to competitors, let’s talk. Brand Butter Marketing helps local businesses stand out and win on Google.


Recent Posts

Glass skyscraper with red logo, street view, city buildings, dusk in Fredericton
By Lynda Ofume September 9, 2025
Discover simple digital marketing strategies Fredericton businesses can use to attract more customers and grow online.
Hopewell Rocks Coastal rocks with trees against a beige-colored sea under a light blue sky.
By Lynda Ofume September 9, 2025
Discover the most Instagram-worthy spots in Atlantic Canada. Businesses can use these iconic locations for social media content and brand storytelling.
Lobster roll with a generous portion of lobster salad on a toasted bun, served on a white plate.
By Lynda Ofume September 9, 2025
What if Atlantic Canada’s iconic foods—donair, lobster rolls, and blueberries—had their own ad campaigns? A fun, creative take on regional marketing.